Stubborn dogs can be pretty frustrating. They refuse to listen, bark incessantly, pull on your leash when you take them out, and more. When you get the best training collar for stubborn dogs, you can use it to train your dog to behave better.
If you are in a hurry to see the best we’ve selected, then check the SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainer as the Best Overall and the Patapet dog training collar as the best alternative. These are the top stubborn dog collars to order. They were selected as the best due to their training effectiveness, high quality, battery life, charging time, extensive dog training features, and more. You may wish to click here to jump straight to reviews of each product.
These stubborn dog collars can help you to correct specific frustrating behaviors in a dog. They can also help with aggression, barking, chewing, and other behavioral problems. Also, depending on your chosen settings and the type of dog collar purchased, your dog can receive instant feedback from the collar to stop a particular action, whether you are present or not.
However, you should know that when choosing a collar for stubborn dogs, there are many products in the market, making it challenging to pick one. You need to know what to look for in the best training collar for dogs that pull or obstinate dogs.
This is why further down after the products, we have also included buyers guide to help you pick your perfect product. There are also training tips further down to help you train a stubborn dog more effectively.
What Is The Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs?
Here is the ultimate list of stubborn dog collars below. Do note that all of the collars are listed randomly and superb options, as we included only the best in the list. Therefore, feel free to order any product you may find suitable.
- SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers
- PATPET Dog Training Collar
- PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar
- TWODEER Dog Training Collar
- NVK Shock Collars for Dogs with Remote
- Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs
- FunniPets Dog Training Collar
- DogRook Rechargeable Dog Bark Collar
- NBJU Bark Collar for Dogs
- DOG CARE Dog Training Collar with Remote
- Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
- Enrivik Small Size Dog Training Collar with Remote
- F-color Dog Training Collar
- GoodBoy Mini No Shock Remote Collar
This high drive dog collar is designed explicitly for stubborn dogs. It’s an e-collar with a high stimulation range and three training modes. This includes vibration, 21 levels of static simulation, and tone modes.
The SportDOG 425X has a 500-yard range. You can use one remote to train up to 3 dogs at a time, so it’s multi-functional. The collar is waterproof and submersible for up to 25 feet. It uses dryer technology to keep the moisture out.
The remote for the device features simple buttons for adjusting the intensity – high, medium, and low. There’s also an on/off switch on the collar. You can regulate the stimulation directly from the collar.
This dog collar features two rechargeable lithium-ion batteries.
They’re fast-charging batteries that take only 2 hours to get charged. On a full charge, the batteries can last 50 to 70 hours.
The collar is suitable for dogs weighing 8 pounds or higher. Also, it fits dogs with 5 to 22 inches wide necks.
- Dryer technology
- 500-yard range
- Fast charging batteries
- Three training modes
- High stimulation
- You can use it with up to 3 dogs
- Switch on from remote or collar
- Sound only modes are available
The PATPET Dog Training Collar features three training modes to train your pet properly. You can use the beep, vibration, or shock levels ranging from 1-16.
It has a range of 1000 yards which makes it ideal for training from a distance. This stimulation and vibration remote training collar is IPX5 rainproof and IPX7 waterproof dog training collar.
It features blind operation buttons such that you can operate it without looking at it. You can start with the lowest shock level and gradually increase it to match your pet’s temperament.
You can count on the long-lasting battery for long training hours. Both collar and remote control feature long-lasting batteries.
The collar lasts up to 100 days on standby and up to 10 days with regular use. The remote can last up to a year on standby and up to 20 days with everyday use.
The PATPET is suitable for dogs weighing from 10 to 140 lbs.
- Blind operation
- Waterproof and rainproof
- Long-lasting batteries
- 1000 yards range
- Three training modes
- Multi-color options
- Remote is always on
This training shock collar from PetSpy uses electric shock, vibration, and beep. It’s a remote trainer e-collar made with durable non-slip material; it’s waterproof.
You can use dog training or dog shock collars like this to train your pet from as far as 650 yards away. Notably, it’s a reliable stubborn dog bark collar. It also helps tackle aggressive leash pulling and wandering off.
This dog shock collar has 16 adjustable shock levels, and the collar is optimized for blind operation with a touch distinguishing button. You can tell which button does what by just feeling it.
The PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar features a quick dual charge. You can charge it using the split cable and powerful adapter, and it charges very fast.
Dogs that weigh 10 to 140 lbs can use this collar conveniently, and the collar is strong yet relatively light as it weighs just 9 ounces. When you purchase this stubborn dog collar, you get a free dog training guide, so you have your training system ready to go.
- 650 yards range
- Free dog training guide
- Dual quick charge
- Collar strap too long for some dogs
- Not the best battery duration
The TWODEER Dog Training Collar is an IPX7 waterproof training collar with three training modes – beep, vibration, and shock. It’s suitable for large, medium, and also small dogs. The black and yellow color is intuitive.
The TWODEER Dog Training Collar has a remote control range of 550 ft. Furthermore, you can use one remote for two dogs.
The collar features a fixed conductive silicone cover to protect your pet. There’s an extra part of the collar which you can remove if it’s too long for your pet.
The dog collar and the remote both use lithium-ion batteries which you can charge with a USB. You can charge using about any source, including sockets, power banks, and also laptops. It does come with an adapter.
The receiver can last up to 15 days when on standby, but it lasts for about eight days with regular use. In addition, the remote can last up to 90 days, but it lasts for about 25 days with regular use.
- 550 ft range
- Conductive silicone cover
- Lasting remote battery
- The extra strap is removable
- Few intensity levels
- Poor receiver battery
Beep, vibration, and static are the three training modes the collar features. There are nine different vibration modes and up to 99 different shock levels.
The collar will work from an extended range of 1600 feet. Also, you can control up to 4 collars with one remote. A unique feature of the NVK Shock Collar is the security lock.
You can lock the buttons to avoid accidentally switching it on and hurting your pet when you set your ideal training mode. The collar also supports the blind operation.
This collar has dual batteries, and there’s a status display bar in the remote. You can charge via the magnetic micro USB port, and both remote and receiver are long-lasting.
The remote and receiver last up to 15 days on standby, respectively; it takes 2 to 3 hours to charge fully. The collar is IPX7 waterproof and is suitable for dogs weighing 10 to 110 lbs.
- IPX7 waterproof
- Security lock
- 1600 ft range
- 99 shock levels
- Buttons are easily pressed
- Requires regular pairing
If you’d like to train your pet in style, the design of this collar will interest you. This unique product from Bousnic features beep, vibration, and safe shock training modes.
With this collar, you can train your pet from 1000 feet away. You can also use it at the pool or when it rains, as it’s IPX7 water-resistant. The collar features a larger LED screen than most other products.
You can use the remote without looking at it as it supports the blind operation. You’ll find the remote easy to operate with the sleek design. It features a security keypad lock to avoid accidental operation.
The Bousnic Shock Training Collar comes with a rechargeable lithium-ion battery. You can fully charge the battery in 2 to 3 hours, and the receiver will last up to 11 to 15 days. The remote can last up to a month.
Small, medium, and large dogs from 8 to 120 lbs can use this collar.
- Large LED Screen
- Security keypad lock
- 1000 ft range
- IPX7 water-resistant
- Collar straps too long for some dogs
This is a dog training device that comes with four training modes. They include light, static, shock, and vibration modes. It’s a training collar for medium to large dogs who weigh over 20 lbs.
Notably, you can adjust the collar length between 7 to about 26 inches. In addition, the collar isn’t heavy as it weighs just 13.6 ounces.
The FunniPets Dog Training Collar has one of the most extended ranges you’ll get as it’ll work if you’re 2600 Ft away. It’s an IP65 waterproof collar which makes it durable.
The collar is safe to use. There’s a soft rubber cover with a static shock head to protect your pet’s skin. Also, there’s a built-in bright led light to keep your pet visible when it’s dark.
The collar works with three lithium-ion 1 AA batteries. On a full charge, the battery can last for 2 to 3 days. Although this isn’t bad, it’s relatively poor considering the battery life of the other dog collars.
- Soft rubber cap
- Built-in LED Light
- Four training modes
- 2600 ft range
- The battery duration could be longer
- Not for small dogs
If your dog isn’t very stubborn, this no-shock barking collar from DogRook will interest you. It features only vibration and beep training modes. You can use it to train small, medium, and large dogs.
Unlike most other products, this one doesn’t feature a remote. Instead, it works automatically following a built-in mechanism.
This DogRook rechargeable dog bark collar is made with strong, durable, materials including a highly reflective nylon strap. It’s suitable for dogs weighing 11 to 110 lbs and 9 to 22 inches neck sizes.
The collar features two power modes, and after a full charge, you can use it for up to 14 days before recharging. You can use it to train your pet in snow or rain as it’s waterproof.
When you purchase this product, you get a free prong cover to keep it secure when not in use. There’s also the USB charger.
- Durable construction
- Free prong cover
- Highly reflective nylon strap
- Not ideal if you need a shock collar
- Buttons are a bit hard to press
The NBJU Bark Collar for Dogs is an Amazon Best Seller in the Bark Collars category. It’s also reliable in stopping all-around stubborn behavior. It features beep and vibration modes with seven adjustable levels.
You can get this collar in your favorite color, including black, green, blue, orange, and white. It’s a durable piece made with leather and two silicone sleeves to protect your pet’s skin.
The collar doesn’t come with a remote. Instead, there are buttons on one part of the collar so you can set the training modes & levels before your pet puts it on.
The NBJU Bark Collar for Dogs has a lasting battery. It takes just 30 minutes to charge fully and can work for up to 12 days. You can charge with a car charger, power bank, or laptop.
The collar is about 25 inches long. However, it’s adjustable and would fit dogs with 8 to 25 inches wide necks. The weight recommendation is 11 lbs to 110 lbs.
- Multi-color options
- Fast charging
- Durable construction
- Silicon sleeves
- No remote
- Not very easy to navigate
Are you on a low budget? If yes, this Dog Care collar is one of the most affordable training collars for stubborn dogs you’ll find. It features beep, shock, and vibration training modes.
You’ll find this collar and remote convenient to use due to the compact size and intuitive design. Also, this waterproof rechargeable dog collar is lightweight as it weighs just 11.7 ounces.
This collar has a control range of about 600 ft, and thanks to the static intensity dial, you can efficiently operate the remote with one hand. It features a security keypad lock to avoid misoperation.
There are about ten intensity levels in total, and with one remote, you can control two collars. The collar is IP67 waterproof and rainproof so that you can use it in any condition.
Both collar and remote are rechargeable via USB. On a full charge, the Dog Care Dog Training Collar can last for about 15 days.
- IP67 waterproof and rainproof
- 600 ft range
- Security keypad lock
- Compact remote
- Short prongs
The Educator is a unique training collar and an ideal one to train from very long ranges. You can get it in yellow, zen, purple, black, or upland yellow colors.
The collar has a ½ mile range with stimulation, beep, and vibration training modes. Notably, it features some of the lowest stimulation levels for more humane training.
Once you get the best simulation level, you can use the Lock and Set feature to prevent misoperation. The remote – or transmitter – is stopwatch style which you’ll find very easy to use.
Both the collar and transmitter are waterproof and shock-resistant to keep you safe. There’s a LED light on the collar to keep your pet visible when it’s dark.
The collar uses lithium-polymer rechargeable batteries with double chargers. It takes about 2 hours to charge fully. You get a two-year warranty when you buy this product and also free phone support.
- Low stimulation levels
- Free phone support
- Various simulation levels from 1 to 100
- Lock and Set feature
- LED Light
- Stopwatch-style remote
- Fast charging batteries
- Two Year Warranty
- Not the longest battery time
The Enrivik Small Size Dog Training Collar with Remote is one for small stubborn pups. The weight recommendation is 5 – 15 lbs. it’ll fit 8 to 26 inches neck sizes.
This collar has a 1000 ft range. It’s tested to stop stubborn behaviors like pulling on leash, excessive barking, aggression, and disobedience, to name a few.
The collar features a minimalist durable design and is waterproof. You can train up to 4 dogs with one remote. There are silicon caps to keep your pet safe.
When not in use for 5 minutes, it automatically turns off to save power. The battery can last for about 14 days on a full charge which takes about 2 to 3 hours.
When you purchase this dog collar, you get a free training dog guide. The training guide explains how to use the collar to reinforce positive behaviors.
- For small dogs
- Training guide
- 1000 ft range
- Not for big dogs
- Complains of old batteries
This 4-mode dog training collar from the F-color store is beep, vibration, shock, and LED Light. It’s a super long-range dog collar as you can use the receiver from 2600 ft away.
This F-color Dog Training Collar is durable as it’s IP65 waterproof. Also, it features a conductive silicone sleeve which will be more comfortable and safe on your pet’s skin.
The collar is about 65 cm long, and you can adjust it to as short as 18 cm. The strap is also soft and comfortable. Thanks to the blue backlight and LCD, you can use the remote and collar both day and night.
The LED Light will keep your pet visible when it’s dark. You can use one remote to control up to 3 collars. The collar comes with rechargeable lithium-ion batteries.
When you purchase this F-color Dog Training Collar, you get a detailed user manual and dog training guide.
- 2600 ft range
- Blue backlight
- Dog training guide
- IP65 Waterproof
- Plastic material
- Not the best for small dogs
If you prefer no shock collars, here’s another option you might consider. It’s a dog collar for extra small to medium dogs and features just beep and vibration training modes.
The remote will work over a 1000 ft range. Like most other products on this list, this one is waterproof. The compact design of the remote makes it easy to use.
In addition, there’s a large display with clear symbols and self-explanatory settings. You can connect and control two collars with one remote.
The collar comes with a charging adapter. On a full charge, the battery can last for a week. When inactive for 5 minutes, it automatically switches to standby mode to save power.
As it’s a mini remote collar, you shouldn’t use it for pets who weigh above 15 lbs. You get a detailed training guide with up to 15 useful commands and other information on understanding your pet.
- Training guide
- Compact remote
- 1000 ft range
- For extra small to medium dogs
- Not for big dogs
- Not ideal if you need a shock collar
Buying Guide: How To Choose The Best Training Collar For Dogs That Pull And Stubborn Dogs
This buying guide aims to ensure you buy a suitable training collar for your specific needs. We’ll look at important factors to consider when purchasing a dog collar:
The breed of your dog is the first factor to consider while choosing dog collars. As you may be aware, dog breeds vary in size and hair type. The best collar won’t cause discomfort and fur loss around the neck.
Also, most breed-specific collars are adjustable to accommodate puppies as they grow. Aside from size and fur, many dog breeds have distinct personalities.
Since you’re considering a collar for stubborn dogs, you should know that some dog breeds are way more stubborn than others.
Hence, make sure the collar you pick complements your dog’s behavior. Luckily, most collars state which breeds they are best suited.
Most pet owners think a collar that fits around a dog’s neck is the proper size, but that’s not the case. A loose-fitting collar will undoubtedly result in it sliding off all the time.
A tight-fitting collar, on the other hand, might cause recurring pain and irritation to your pet. Knowing your dog’s breed and estimated adult size isn’t enough. Even dogs from the same bloodline vary in height and weight.
To choose a collar based on size, measure your dog’s neck circumference at maturity. Then add extra collar length to avoid a too-tight fit. Small dogs weighing 10 pounds or less can have a 1-inch collar allowance.
Medium-sized dogs weighing 11 to 79 pounds should be OK with a 2-inch additional collar, while large dogs weighing 80 pounds or more will need 3 inches extra.
For pets with long fur, the collar’s fit tightens as the hair thickens. Hence, you should measure their neck circumference after and shortly before grooming. Generally, make sure the collar fits your dog adequately regardless of the fur length.
Not all collars are reliable. Manufacturers use different materials in producing collars of various qualities. When picking a collar for your pet, you cannot skip the material type. Aesthetics, durability, and comfort all depend on the collar’s material. See our post on the best dog collar for sensitive skin if your dog has a sensitive neck.
Material-wise, nylon webbing collars are the most common. It’s tough, light, non-irritating, and most of all, cheap. If you go for a nylon collar, make sure it’s very comfortable.
Standard nylon collars can irritate dogs’ necks, especially if they are too tight or have short fur. However, it’s different with comfort nylon webbing collars due to their enhanced texture, weave, and flexibility.
Hemp is another popular material, and like nylon, it’s firm. It’s woven with natural hemp fibers for durability and comfort. Also, they are usually non-dyed, which means the absence of toxic chemicals in the manufacturing process.
Leather collars are always an option for a more traditional look. They are tough and can tolerate severe use from large breeds. The only disadvantage is that they are relatively more expensive than hemp and nylon.
There are shock training collars for stubborn dogs; others use simulation, vibration, and beep. You’ll have to consider these various training options to know which will work best for your pet.
You don’t want something that’s too mild and will be less effective in correcting stubbornness. Also, you don’t want to use something too harsh that’ll harm your pet.
Another vital training feature is the range. Long-range collars are always best so you can correct your pet’s bad behavior from a distance. Fortunately, most remote training collars have long ranges and can work over far distances.
The battery of your remote training collars tells you how long you can use it. Simply put, the longer the battery life, the better.
You have to consider the battery of the receiver and transmitter. Furthermore, you should consider the charging pattern too.
Finally, you’ll want to pick a design that both you and your pet will like. The colors and patterns of collars vary, so choose something pleasing to the eye, or your pet may dislike it.
You should pick products that balance safety and security with attractiveness. Reflective collar surfaces and colors help you discover your dog after dark.
How To Train A Stubborn Dog
Buying the best training collar for stubborn dogs may not entirely solve the problem. Sometimes, stubbornness isn’t the pet’s fault.
Often, we owners cause the behavior if they don’t train or treat our pets well. Whether your dog is stubborn, confused, or simply distracted, these tips will help train stubborn dogs successfully:
Train In Different Settings
Your pet may only act stubborn in specific environments. For example, they may be the perfect pet at home, but all training is lost with all the distractions when you go to the park.
Not training outdoors is a common mistake some owners make in dog training. You have more control over your environment at home, so it’s easy to control your pet. However, when outside, your dog can discover new things, people, and smells.
These will easily distract and overstimulate your pet. Hence, it’s not enough to only train your pet indoors. It would help if you taught your dog how to focus in a variety of situations.
Your dog will learn essential impulse control by training outside. They’ll get to understand what you expect from them in different situations. Practice your fundamental obedience commands on the street, garden center, and dog park.
Generally, aim to have at least one of your weekly training sessions somewhere new.
Offer Better Treats
If you’re still using conventional dog food or dog biscuits for training dogs, it’s time to step up. Your dog may be reluctant to listen because the rewards you offer are no longer appealing.
Most dogs are food-motivated. If your pet is, try training with chicken, fish, or cheese. These are a lot more appealing to dogs.
For example, you can call out basic commands like sit and come right before stepping out and then give your pet a treat if they obey the command. This is the best way to teach recall as he will associate treats with obeying commands.
You can randomly call your pet over and give them the new treats as they play. When you indulge them with high-value treats, they will return for more. When it’s time to put your dog back on the leash, you won’t have to chase your dog around as your pet will come willingly.
With practice, your pet will get very familiar with this training. If your dog is more toy-oriented, treat your pet with their favorite toy. Treats may not be as important to them as time spent playing with you. Generally, you should find your dog’s motivation and leverage it.
Ensure Your Commands Are Clear
In some circumstances, how you say commands may be the cause of your dog’s stubborn behavior. It’s either your pet doesn’t understand, or your request is unclear.
You may be confusing your dog if your family offers different commands for the same behavior. For example, if you say come while others come here, your dog may find it hard to comprehend both.
Hence, during training, you should use clear and precise instructions. Also, you should avoid saying commands repeatedly; just tell them once. For example, saying sit sit sit repeatedly weakens its hold. It doesn’t reinforce the command; it merely encourages stalling.
It’s is also possible that your dog doesn’t understand the command. If so, go back to the basics and teach the command again until it works.
If your dog understands but is stubborn, keep your tone low, firm, and confident, and repeat the command one more time. Take a step forward while maintaining eye contact. This should restore control.
All commands should be confident and authoritative. Your dog will not listen to a high-pitched or submissive voice. Only use elevated tones when praising your dog for obedience.
Don’t Use Punishment.
Training can become stressful and threatening for your dog if you constantly yell at or punish your pet. It won’t be a fun event that your dog looks forward to, but something to fear.
If your dog is afraid you might scare him at any minute, he won’t concentrate and won’t learn. You will also lose the possibility of building a close bond with your pet. The best training results come from a strong mutual respect connection and not punishment.
Only engage in positive training. If your dogs do anything improper, redirect or ignore it. If they’re gnawing on furniture, for example, loudly clap to distract them. You can alternate chews such as rope toys, antlers, and buffalo horns. Generally, always maintain a calm demeanor when training your dog.
Often, dog owners teach their dog’s basic commands, but training stops as the puppy ages. The behaviors they learn gradually deteriorate until they forget everything.
Regular practice should refine and strengthen their behaviors. Aim to teach your pet new commands now and then to keep their minds engaged and grow your influence.
Carry out daily or weekly training sessions and employ the commands you teach in everyday circumstances. This helps your dog remember the instructions, resulting in a more obedient reaction.
Make It Fun
Training should be a fun experience for your dog. When teaching a new command, praise and appreciate obedience. For instance, when teaching your pet to wait, go slowly and reward them if they remain motionless. You should always do this right away.
Incremental rewards make training fun and rewarding for your dog, encouraging them to stay focused. However, you should add fun activities from time to time.
If you only bark instructions without engaging in fun, your dog will always be confused and frustrated. Try to end all training sessions on a positive note.
Your pet can quickly become agitated and disinterested if you teach them a new command they can’t learn. So at the end of training sessions, call out commands they understand.
Know When To Have A Break
You may be overtraining your dog if he quickly loses interest during working sessions. Dogs do better with shorter training sessions throughout the day; else they end up feeling tired.
You can train in 5 3-minute sessions rather than one entire 15-minute session. Do a quick energy check during training. If your dog ignores your commands and moves away, it may be time to stop the session. Simply finish with a simple command and resume in a few hours.
Do Harnesses Keep Dogs From Pulling?
A harness reduces the strain on your pet’s neck and back by dispersing pressure over a broader region of his body. Hence, it does discourage pulling. See our post on how to train a dog to wear a harness.
Should Dog Collars Be Removed Overnight?
Keeping your dog’s collar on overnight can sometimes cause injuries and could make your dog unable to sleep. If you have a safe place such as a dog cage, dog crate, locked space, or some other secure place to protect your pet, you should opt to take off your dog’s collar overnight.
What Is The Law On Dog Collars?
The Law in the USA requires that dogs be restrained in public. Also, in the UK, the law requires that dogs wear collars in public. Owners must also guarantee that the dog’s collar displays their name and address to avoid getting a fine. Hence, in the eyes of the law, collars are a must.
Can Dogs Wear A Harness And Collar?
Yes, your dog can wear a collar and a harness simultaneously for more security and control when out walking. Using both will give you more control than if you use just a collar or just a harness.
I’ve listed the best training collars for dogs that pull, stubborn dogs, and more in this article. In the end, you’ll have to settle for one.
I’ll recommend the SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainer as the overall best training collar for stubborn dogs. It is a high-quality collar specifically designed for training stubborn dogs. The collar is waterproof and rainproof and can work on multiple dogs at the same time if needed. It can be used over a far range of 500 yards and charges very quickly, which will save you time. This is a premium dog training collar, and it is indeed a great buy.
The best alternative to sportDOG will be the PATPET Dog Training Collar. This collar also has three training modes to help you train your pet. It goes as far as 1000 yards and is also waterproof and rainproof. It has long-lasting battery life and can do up to 100 days standby. This collar is also a great buy.
Finally, If you prioritize price, you can go for the DOG CARE Dog Training Collar with Remote. This lightweight device can go as far as 600ft, and the collars and the remote are rechargeables. It is also rainproof and waterproof to a reasonable extent, and the battery can do up to 15 days. Even though it is not as premium quality as the rest and has short prongs, It is still a good buy for the price and will help you train your dog.
I hope you enjoyed our reviews on the best training collar for dogs that pull and stubborn dogs. Please share it with your friends.